Quick answer: if your paycheck is less than expected, the most common reasons are local income taxes that general calculators skip, pre-tax deductions such as health insurance and 401(k), a W-4 that withholds more than you thought, and first or partial pay periods. Local taxes alone can take 1% to 3.7% of your pay in some US cities.
1. Local income taxes
Many paycheck calculators handle federal and state tax but skip local taxes. If you live or work in one of these places, expect an extra line on your paystub:
| Place |
Local tax on wages (2026) |
| Philadelphia |
3.735% residents, 3.425% non-residents |
| Detroit |
2.4% residents, 1.2% non-residents |
| Most large Ohio cities |
2.5% (Youngstown 2.75%) |
| Most of Pennsylvania |
Usually 1% to 2% local EIT |
| Other Michigan cities |
Usually 1% residents, 0.5% non-residents |
On a $60,000 salary, a 2.5% city tax is $1,500 a year, or about $58 per biweekly paycheck.
Calculators for these places: Philadelphia, Detroit, Ohio cities and Pennsylvania local EIT.
2. Pre-tax deductions
Health, dental and vision premiums, 401(k) contributions, HSA and FSA contributions all come out before you're paid. They reduce your taxes but also your take-home pay.
3. Your W-4
If you checked "multiple jobs", entered extra withholding, or didn't claim dependents you could have, more federal tax is withheld than your actual liability. That money comes back as a refund, but it makes each paycheck smaller.
4. Your first paycheck
A first paycheck may cover only part of a pay period, or arrive before your pay rate was set up in payroll.
5. Pay frequency
Being paid every two weeks gives 26 paychecks a year, not 24. Dividing your salary by 24 overstates each paycheck by about 8%. Two months a year you'll get three paychecks.
6. Bonus withholding
Bonuses are often withheld at a flat 22% federal rate, plus state and local tax. A bonus check can look small even though your final tax works out the same.
7. Social Security stops and starts
High earners stop paying Social Security once wages pass $184,500 in 2026, so paychecks grow late in the year. In January they shrink again.
8. Mid-year rate changes
Philadelphia lowers its wage tax every July 1, and benefit costs often change at open enrollment. A change in one paycheck may simply be a new rate starting.
How to find the cause
Lay your paystub next to an estimate. Match each line: gross pay, each tax, each deduction. The line that's different tells you where to look. If it's a local tax line you didn't expect, check whether your city or school district taxes wages and whether payroll has your correct home address.
A worked example: why the first paycheck looked small
Jordan was offered $60,000 and divided by 24 to expect $2,500 per paycheck before tax. The first biweekly paycheck showed $2,307.69 gross and a much smaller net. Here's what explained it:
| Reason |
Effect per paycheck |
| Paid every two weeks, not twice a month: $60,000 ÷ 26 |
Gross is $2,307.69, not $2,500 |
| Health insurance premium |
−$85 |
| 401(k) at 5% |
−$115.38 |
| Lives in a 2.5% Ohio city |
−$57.69 city tax |
None of it was an error. The city tax line was the one Jordan's online calculator had left out.
How to check each line in ten minutes
- Gross pay: salary ÷ number of paychecks a year (52, 26, 24 or 12).
- Pre-tax deductions: match each benefit to your enrollment.
- Federal tax: compare with an estimate using your W-4 details.
- Social Security and Medicare: 6.2% and 1.45% of wages after cafeteria-plan deductions.
- State tax: your state's rate or brackets.
- Local tax: check whether your city, county or school district taxes wages, using the calculators for DC, Philadelphia, Detroit, Ohio cities or Pennsylvania EIT.
The line that doesn't match is your answer.
When it is an error
Sometimes the paycheck really is wrong. Signs to raise with payroll:
- Wrong local tax for where you live or work, often after a move
- Wrong pay rate or hours
- Benefits you didn't choose, or a deduction that should have ended
- Tax for the wrong state, common for remote workers whose home address isn't updated
Most payroll teams can fix withholding from the next paycheck and adjust earlier ones.
When your paycheck gets bigger instead
Paychecks can also rise unexpectedly: when you pass the Social Security wage base of $184,500, when a benefit deduction ends, or when a city lowers its rate, as Philadelphia does each July. Knowing why it changed helps you plan.
Note that being paid 26 times a year doesn't lose Jordan any money: 26 × $2,307.69 is the same $60,000. It only makes each paycheck smaller than dividing by 24 suggests.