How this calculator works
Car makers (not dealers) commonly offer two mutually exclusive incentives on the same model: a cash rebate (sometimes called "customer cash") that comes off the price, or a promotional APR that is well below market rates — often as low as 0% to 1.9% for a limited term. You can take one or the other, almost never both. The right answer depends on the size of the rebate, how low the promotional APR is, how low your fallback rate is, and the loan term.
Option 1 (promotional APR): finance the car at the low promotional rate, forgoing the rebate. The payment is calculated on the full price minus your down payment, at the promotional APR, over the chosen term. The lower rate reduces total interest, but the full price stays financed.
Option 2 (rebate): subtract the rebate from the price up front, then finance the smaller amount at your own bank, credit-union or lender rate (your "shopping" rate). The rebate reduces the balance that interest is charged on; your own rate is almost always higher than the manufacturer's promotional rate.
The calculator computes the total of payments for each option over the same term, so the comparison is apples to apples. The winner is whichever option's total is lower; the difference is the real dollar advantage.
Rules of thumb. The rebate wins when it is large, your own rate is already low, the term is short, or the promotional APR is close to your own rate anyway. The low APR wins when the rebate is modest, your own rate is high, and the term is long enough for compounding interest to matter.
Before you decide, get a pre-approval from your bank or credit union so you know your real alternative rate — otherwise the dealer's F&I desk will tell you whatever rate they can mark up without you being able to check. Promotional APRs almost always require tier-1 credit (usually 740+), so confirm you qualify before building a decision around that option.
Worked example
$36,000 car, $4,000 down, choose $3,000 rebate OR 0.9% APR, your bank's rate 6.5%, 60-month term
- Option 1 — 0.9% APR, no rebate: financing $32,000 at 0.9% for 60 months = $545.62 a month, $32,737 total.
- Option 2 — $3,000 rebate, bank at 6.5%: financing $29,000 at 6.5% for 60 months = about $567 a month, about $34,045 total.
- The 0.9% APR wins by about $1,308 over the life of the loan — mostly because 0.9% for 5 years is cheaper interest than the 6.5% alternative, even on a $3,000 larger balance.
- Flip the numbers: at a $5,000 rebate (instead of $3,000) the rebate wins; at a 2.9% promotional APR (instead of 0.9%) the rebate wins; at a 48-month term the gap shrinks.
Common mistakes
- Comparing the monthly payments instead of the total of payments. A longer term always lowers the payment but can raise the total.
- Taking the dealer's "we checked and your bank rate is X" at face value. Pre-approve before visiting the dealership so you have a locked alternative to compare with.
- Assuming you qualify for the promotional APR before credit check. Advertised rates are tier-1 only; the rate your paperwork actually quotes may be different.
Limitations of this calculator
- Assumes a single fixed-rate auto loan on both sides. Does not model variable-rate loans, balloon payments or lease deals.
- Does not include dealer fees, documentation fees or sales tax; those apply equally to both options and cancel out in the comparison.
- Does not model trade-in equity on either side. If you have a trade-in, add it to the down payment on both options.
For your specific situation, consult a tax professional or financial advisor.
Questions people ask
When does the rebate usually win over the promotional APR?
When the rebate is large relative to the price (say, $5,000+ on a $36,000 car), the term is short (36 or 48 months, so there is less time for interest to accumulate), the promotional APR is only mildly below your own rate, or your own rate is already low (sub-4%). Also when you plan to pay the car off early — a long-term promo APR is wasted if you plan to clear the loan in year 2.
Do I need top-tier credit for promotional rates?
Usually yes — "tier 1" or "tier 1+", generally 740+ FICO. Dealers advertise the promotional APR as the headline rate but it is only available to the top credit tier; everyone else sees "or" with a sliding scale. Confirm your tier before building a decision around the promotional rate; a 1.9% advertised rate becoming 5.9% at tier 3 flips the math.
Can I take both the rebate and the promotional APR?
Rarely. The two are usually mutually exclusive — the manufacturer funds one incentive per unit, and dealers cannot stack them. A few programs allow a small combined offer (reduced rebate + reduced promo rate); ask specifically whether both can be stacked and get the answer in writing.
Is the rebate taxable or does it count as income?
A manufacturer rebate is treated as a reduction of the purchase price, not income to you. Some states still calculate state sales tax on the pre-rebate price (so the rebate does not reduce sales tax); others calculate sales tax on the post-rebate price. Check your state DMV or the dealer's itemised sales-tax line.
What about dealer discounts and manufacturer rebates together?
These usually stack — a dealer discount comes from the dealer's margin, a manufacturer rebate from the automaker. The two are independent and both can be taken, along with any promotional APR (if offered). Negotiate the dealer price first, then separately choose rebate OR low APR.
Sources
Last reviewed October 2, 2026 · Last reviewed by Muhammad Ahmad on October 31, 2026