How this calculator works
When RSUs vest, their fair market value is treated as ordinary W-2 wages. Your employer must withhold federal income tax at the 22% supplemental rate (37% above $1M of supplemental wages in a year), Social Security (6.2% up to the $184,500 wage base), Medicare (1.45% + 0.9% above the threshold), and state withholding.
The 22% federal supplemental is almost always too low for RSU recipients. If your marginal bracket is 24% or higher, you will owe a top-up at tax time — commonly 2–15% of vest value. Most tech employers do not increase withholding automatically; you must file a W-4 line 4(c) adjustment or make quarterly estimated payments.
Many RSU plans "sell to cover" — the broker sells enough shares at vest to cover the mandatory withholding, delivering the rest to your brokerage account. You can also elect "net share settlement" (shares reduced), "cash settlement" (employer deducts from salary) or deposit the full share count and pay withholding separately.
After vest, the shares have a cost basis equal to the vest-day price. If you sell within one year of vest, any gain is a short-term capital gain, taxed at ordinary rates. Held more than one year, it is a long-term capital gain, taxed at 0%, 15%, or 20% depending on taxable income.
Watch the "double tax" trap. Form 1099-B from your broker reports the basis as what you paid (typically $0 for RSUs), not the vest-day price that was already taxed as wages on your W-2. On Form 8949 and Schedule D, you must adjust the basis up to the vest price — otherwise you will pay tax twice on the same income.
Worked example
500 shares vest at $180, California single filer, $180K base salary, held one year, sold at $210
- Vest value: 500 × $180 = $90,000 added to your W-2 as ordinary income.
- Federal 22% supplemental withholding: $19,800. (Your real marginal bracket at $270K combined income is ~32%, so expect a top-up of about $9,000 at tax time.)
- California 10.23% supplemental withholding (special CA rate for supplemental wages): $9,207.
- Social Security (6.2% up to $184,500 wage base): some but likely partial given your base already consumed it. Medicare 1.45%: $1,305.
- Held > 1 year, sold at $210: long-term capital gain = ($210 − $180) × 500 = $15,000. Federal LTCG at 15% = $2,250. California adds ~$1,500 (CA taxes LTCG at ordinary rates).
- Total tax on this one vest and sale: roughly $42,000 — a 40% effective rate once you add top-up and sale tax.
Questions people ask
Why do I owe tax when I file if 22% was already withheld?
The 22% federal supplemental rate is a flat withholding rate, not a real bracket. Most RSU recipients have marginal brackets of 24%, 32%, or 35%, so the 22% leaves 2–13% unpaid. Fix this prospectively by increasing W-4 line 4(c) withholding, or by paying quarterly estimates.
What is "sell to cover" and should I use it?
The broker sells just enough shares at vest to cover the mandatory withholding and deposits the net shares to your account. This is the default at most employers and is usually fine. The alternative is paying cash for the withholding and keeping all the shares — only worth it if you have conviction the stock will rise.
How is the cost basis set on RSUs?
The vest-day fair market value is your cost basis. Form 1099-B often reports it as $0 (what you literally paid), so you must adjust on Form 8949 and Schedule D using the "Adjusted basis" column, with code B. Missing this adjustment is the single most common RSU tax mistake and causes double-taxation of the vest income.
Does California tax RSUs differently?
California applies a special 10.23% flat supplemental withholding on bonuses and RSUs — higher than most states' bracket method. California does not conform to federal long-term capital gains rates: all gains are taxed at ordinary CA rates up to 13.3%. Allocation to the pre-move state applies if you vest after relocating from California.
What if my company IPO'd and the stock is now underwater?
You already paid tax at the vest price. Selling below basis creates a capital loss, deductible against capital gains and up to $3,000 of ordinary income per year (carryover above). This does not refund the ordinary tax paid at vest, which is a sunk cost. Many 2021-vintage RSU holders are in this situation.
Should I sell my RSUs immediately or hold?
The decision is risk management. Each unvested RSU is already concentrated to your employer's stock through your salary. Selling at vest and reinvesting the proceeds in a diversified portfolio removes that concentration. Holding bets on your employer outperforming the market, with downside identical to employees who did not get RSUs. Vanguard, Fidelity and most financial planners recommend sell-at-vest for RSUs.
Sources
Last reviewed October 14, 2026