How this calculator works
Federal student loans use fixed rates set by Congress each year. For undergraduate Direct Loans in 2025–26 the rate is 6.53%, graduate Direct Unsubsidized at 8.08%, and Direct PLUS loans for graduate students or parents at 9.08%. Older loans carry whatever rate was in force the year they were disbursed.
Standard Repayment is 10 years of equal monthly payments. On $35,000 at 6.53% that is $397/month and $12,616 total interest. Graduated Repayment starts low and rises every 2 years over 10 years, which lowers early-career cash flow but costs more total interest.
Income-driven repayment caps the monthly payment at 10%–20% of discretionary income (income above 150% of the federal poverty line for your household). On SAVE's successor plan, undergraduates pay 10%; graduate loans pay 15%; mixed borrowers pay a weighted blend. Remaining balance is forgiven after 20–25 years, though the forgiven amount is taxable as income under current rules.
PSLF (Public Service Loan Forgiveness) forgives the remaining balance after 10 years (120 qualifying payments) of full-time work for a government or qualifying non-profit employer. Payments must be on Direct Loans, under an IDR plan, and certified annually. The forgiven amount is NOT taxable for PSLF.
Private loans don't have federal protections — no income-driven options, no PSLF, no death discharge in some cases. Refinancing federal into private is a one-way door; the lower rate is tempting but you lose IDR, forgiveness and forbearance options.
Worked example
$35,000 undergraduate balance at 6.53%, three plans compared
- Standard, 10 years: $397/month × 120 months = $47,616 paid. Interest: $12,616.
- Graduated, 10 years: starts around $240/month, rises every 2 years, ends around $720/month. Total paid: $49,800. Interest: $14,800 (about $2,200 more than Standard).
- IDR (10% of discretionary income). At $45,000 income for a single borrower: discretionary = 45,000 − (1.5 × 15,060 single poverty line 2026) = $22,410. 10% monthly = $187/month. Interest grows unless paid off.
- 20-year IDR: 240 payments averaging ~$215/month (as income rises) = $51,600 paid. Remaining balance after 20 years: ~$12,500. Forgiven, taxable at marginal rate — $3,750 tax hit in a 24% bracket.
- PSLF: 120 payments averaging ~$190/month = $22,800. Forgiven $25,000+ at year 10, tax-free. Best outcome if eligible.
Common mistakes
- Refinancing federal loans into private before trying IDR. The lower rate costs you every federal protection.
- Signing up for Standard without checking IDR for low income. If your income can't cover Standard, missed payments damage credit.
- Expecting PSLF without certifying employment yearly. Many borrowers hit year 10 and discover years weren't counted.
- Treating the stated interest rate as fixed forever. For older variable-rate private loans, rates reset with SOFR.
- Forgetting the tax bomb on 20/25-year IDR forgiveness. Save for the eventual tax owed on the forgiven balance.
Limitations of this calculator
- Uses 2025–26 federal rates. Rates reset July 1 each year for new disbursements; your existing loans keep their original rate.
- IDR calculation uses a simplified "10% of discretionary income" model; actual payment depends on family size, filing status and marriage treatment.
- Does not model Parent PLUS loan treatment (ICR-only, no PSLF for parent borrowers unless consolidated).
- Does not include the one-time 1-year payment pause ("fresh start"), temporary administrative forbearances, or the SAVE litigation hold.
- State-specific loan forgiveness programs (nurses, teachers in certain states) are not covered.
For your specific situation, consult a tax professional or financial advisor.
Questions people ask
Should I refinance federal loans with a private lender?
Only if you have stable high income, don't need IDR or PSLF, and the rate is at least 1.5%–2% lower. You lose income-driven repayment, death discharge in some cases, and all federal forgiveness programs. One-way door.
Does interest accrue during forbearance?
On unsubsidized federal loans and private loans, yes — the balance grows. On subsidized federal loans during deferment (not forbearance), the government pays the interest.
What is the SAVE plan status?
SAVE was blocked by courts in 2024–2025 and replaced by a successor plan under PAYE/IBR terms. Check studentaid.gov for the current plan name and payment calculation — the mechanics in this calculator reflect the general IDR framework.
Can I pay extra on student loans?
Yes, no prepayment penalty on federal or most private loans. Specify "apply to principal" or extra may be banked against the next payment, which doesn't help. On private loans with high rates, aggressive extra payments usually beat IDR.
Is forgiven student debt taxable?
Under IDR 20/25-year forgiveness, yes — the forgiven amount is 1099-C income. PSLF forgiveness is tax-free. State treatment varies.
Sources
Last reviewed October 19, 2026