How this calculator works
Price-to-rent is the quickest filter. Divide the purchase price by the annual rent for a comparable property. Under 15 → buying usually wins long-term. 15–20 → mixed, depends on local tax and appreciation. Over 20 → renting usually wins unless you expect big appreciation. US average sits around 20; San Francisco and NYC often exceed 30.
Buying costs that get ignored: closing (2%–5% of purchase), property tax (0.3%–2.5%/year depending on state), homeowners insurance ($1,000–$3,000/year), maintenance (1% of home value/year is the rule of thumb), HOA (if applicable), PMI if under 20% down, and selling costs (5%–6% of sale price in agent commissions).
The opportunity cost of the down payment matters. $80,000 sitting in a house that appreciates 3%/year is up to $92,500 in 5 years. The same $80,000 in a 7% real-return index portfolio is $112,200. The house wins on leverage (you borrowed $320,000 to control a $400,000 asset), but you also carry all the costs.
Breakeven horizon is usually 3–7 years. On the first mortgage payment most of what you pay goes to interest, not principal, so early selling loses money to transaction costs. The rent-vs-buy breakeven calculator finds the year where cumulative owning cost equals cumulative renting cost.
Tax treatment helps buyers who itemize. Mortgage interest and property tax (capped at $10,000 for SALT) are deductible. If you take the standard deduction ($30,000 married joint 2026), these have no effect on your taxes. Most middle-income families don't itemize at current standard deduction levels.
Worked example
$400,000 home vs $2,300/month rent, 5-year horizon
- Buying: $80,000 down (20%). Mortgage $320,000 at 6.5% for 30 years = $2,023/month P&I.
- Owning monthly: P&I $2,023 + tax 1.1% ÷ 12 × $400K = $367 + insurance $150 + maintenance 1% ÷ 12 × $400K = $333 = $2,873/month, or $172,380 over 5 years.
- Of the 5-year mortgage total ($121,380), $100,590 went to interest and $20,790 to principal — plus any appreciation on the house.
- Renting: $2,300/month × 60 = $138,000 over 5 years. Plus down payment stays invested: $80,000 at 7% real = $112,215 (gain $32,215).
- Buying cost minus principal paid minus 3%/year appreciation on the home: $172,380 − $20,790 − $63,700 = $87,890 "sunk" into ownership.
- Renting + investing: $138,000 rent − $32,215 investment gain = $105,785 sunk.
- 5-year comparison: buying costs about $18,000 less in this scenario, assuming 3% appreciation and no major repairs. The margin narrows fast if appreciation is 0% or if you sell before year 5.
Common mistakes
- Comparing rent to mortgage P&I only. Owning adds tax, insurance, maintenance, HOA — often 50%+ more than the P&I alone.
- Ignoring opportunity cost of the down payment. $80,000 is real money that could compound elsewhere.
- Underestimating transaction costs. Selling costs 5%–6% of sale price in agent commissions, which effectively resets equity for the first 2–3 years.
- Assuming appreciation always matches long-run averages. Local markets vary; some are flat or declining for a decade.
- Overlooking lifestyle costs: lawn care, repairs on your own time, moving flexibility, HOA restrictions.
Limitations of this calculator
- Does not model variable mortgage rates or ARM resets.
- Assumes constant rent inflation; actual rent increases vary 2%–8%/year.
- Does not include a specific maintenance schedule; real maintenance is lumpy (roof, HVAC, appliances) and often exceeds 1% averaged.
- Does not model the tax benefit for itemisers (depends on income, state tax, charitable giving).
- Does not account for mobility risk — hard-to-sell properties in down markets lock you in.
For your specific situation, consult a tax professional or financial advisor.
Questions people ask
How long should I plan to stay to buy?
Typically 5–7 years for buying to beat renting in most US markets. Shorter horizons rarely clear transaction costs (buying + selling eats 7%–10% of the purchase price).
What about building equity?
Only principal payments build equity. On a 6.5% mortgage in year 1, about 15% of each payment is principal; the other 85% is interest. Early-year equity building is slow and asymmetric.
Does appreciation make buying always win?
No. US home appreciation has averaged about 4% nominal (1% real) over long periods. Over 5–10 years, stock-market returns have usually beaten housing on an unleveraged basis. The leverage of a mortgage can tip the scales but adds risk.
What is the tax benefit of buying?
For itemizers (less common after TCJA): mortgage interest deductible on loans up to $750,000, and SALT (property tax + state income tax) capped at $10,000. Most middle-income families take the $30,000 standard deduction and get no incremental tax benefit from buying.
Should I buy with less than 20% down?
You can — FHA (3.5%), conventional (3%+) and VA (0%). You pay PMI or MIP, which raises the monthly cost. Breakeven stretches by 2–4 years. Consider whether putting less down and investing the difference beats PMI cost at current rates.
Sources
Last reviewed October 19, 2026